Jewelry stores in Columbus - TOP 10 ranking

The ranking was created by searching for jewelry stores on Google Maps in Columbus.

We focused on jewelry stores (listed under the business categories: jewelry store and jewelry shop in their Google Business Profile) that did not appear as advertisements. Furthermore, they needed to have an average rating of no less than 4.0 stars on Google, with a maximum number of reviews.

Therefore, we considered organic results from highly-optimized listings of seasoned jewelry stores in Columbus, who prioritize the quality of their offerings and their reputation, as evidenced by customer reviews.

The analysis was conducted using the ReviewsAudit tool. Based on this analysis, we compiled the TOP 10: Best jewelry stores in Columbus. The following text offers a concise comparison, and individual reports with links are provided for each store in the jewelry ranking.

The ranking was created on November 15, 2023.

1. Argo & Lehne Jewelers (3100 Tremont Rd)

Results from ReviewsAudit:

• ReviewsAudit Score (%): 65.3
• Average Rating: 4.79
• Number of Reviews: 52
• New Reviews in the Last Quarter: 9
• Response Rate to Reviews (%): 84.62
• Percentage of Reviews without Text (%): 65.38

The highest-rated best jewelry store in Columbus, according to customer reviews, is Argo & Lehne Jewelers (3100 Tremont Rd). The average rating from all Google reviews for this jewelry store is 4.79 based on 52 reviews. In the last 3 months, Argo & Lehne Jewelers (3100 Tremont Rd) has received 9 new customer reviews.

Additionally, the jewelry store has responded to 84.62% of all customer reviews, which had a significant impact on the final rating displayed in the jewelry store ranking report.

When it comes to review quality, it can be verified using the percentage of reviews without text (the lower the value, the better). For the place in the ranking, the result was 65.38%.

These are some of the variables that influenced the percentage score in ReviewsAudit. For Argo & Lehne Jewelers (3100 Tremont Rd), the score was 65.3%.

Below, we invite you to check the detailed review report in the best jewelry stores ranking in Columbus for the place on the list. Detailed report includes analyses related to customer sentiment, trust score, average growth rate, response time to reviews, average review length, or the impact of negative reviews on the overall rating.

Check the detailed report of the place in ranking

2. Alexanders Jewelers (689 N High St)

Results from ReviewsAudit:

• ReviewsAudit Score (%): 65.06
• Average Rating: 4.88
• Number of Reviews: 113
• New Reviews in the Last Quarter: 20
• Response Rate to Reviews (%): 68.14
• Percentage of Reviews without Text (%): 63.72

The second highest-rated best jewelry store in Columbus, according to customer reviews, is Alexanders Jewelers (689 N High St). The average rating from all Google reviews for this jewelry store is 4.88 based on 113 reviews. In the last 3 months, Alexanders Jewelers (689 N High St) has received 20 new customer reviews.

Additionally, the jewelry store has responded to 68.14% of all customer reviews, which had a significant impact on the final rating displayed in the jewelry store ranking report.

When it comes to review quality, it can be verified using the percentage of reviews without text (the lower the value, the better). For the second place in the ranking, the result was 63.72%.

These are some of the variables that influenced the percentage score in ReviewsAudit. For Alexanders Jewelers (689 N High St), the score was 65.06%.

Below, we invite you to check the detailed review report in the best jewelry stores ranking in Columbus for the second place on the list. Detailed report includes analyses related to customer sentiment, trust score, average growth rate, response time to reviews, average review length, or the impact of negative reviews on the overall rating.

Check the detailed report of the second place in ranking

3. Koulian Jewelers (861 N High St)

Results from ReviewsAudit:

• ReviewsAudit Score (%): 63.99
• Average Rating: 4.9
• Number of Reviews: 39
• New Reviews in the Last Quarter: 10
• Response Rate to Reviews (%): 66.67
• Percentage of Reviews without Text (%): 35.9

The third highest-rated best jewelry store in Columbus, according to customer reviews, is Koulian Jewelers (861 N High St). The average rating from all Google reviews for this jewelry store is 4.9 based on 39 reviews. In the last 3 months, Koulian Jewelers (861 N High St) has received 10 new customer reviews.

Additionally, the jewelry store has responded to 66.67% of all customer reviews, which had a significant impact on the final rating displayed in the jewelry store ranking report.

When it comes to review quality, it can be verified using the percentage of reviews without text (the lower the value, the better). For the third place in the ranking, the result was 35.9%.

These are some of the variables that influenced the percentage score in ReviewsAudit. For Koulian Jewelers (861 N High St), the score was 63.99%.

Below, we invite you to check the detailed review report in the best jewelry stores ranking in Columbus for the third place on the list. Detailed report includes analyses related to customer sentiment, trust score, average growth rate, response time to reviews, average review length, or the impact of negative reviews on the overall rating.

Check the detailed report of the third place in ranking

4. Diamonds Direct Columbus (1330 Polaris Pkwy)

Results from ReviewsAudit:

• ReviewsAudit Score (%): 63.72
• Average Rating: 4.96
• Number of Reviews: 157
• New Reviews in the Last Quarter: 27
• Response Rate to Reviews (%): 28.66
• Percentage of Reviews without Text (%): 68.15

The fourth highest-rated best jewelry store in Columbus, according to customer reviews, is Diamonds Direct Columbus (1330 Polaris Pkwy). The average rating from all Google reviews for this jewelry store is 4.96 based on 157 reviews. In the last 3 months, Diamonds Direct Columbus (1330 Polaris Pkwy) has received 27 new customer reviews.

Additionally, the jewelry store has responded to 28.66% of all customer reviews, which had a significant impact on the final rating displayed in the jewelry store ranking report.

When it comes to review quality, it can be verified using the percentage of reviews without text (the lower the value, the better). For the fourth place in the ranking, the result was 68.15%.

These are some of the variables that influenced the percentage score in ReviewsAudit. For Diamonds Direct Columbus (1330 Polaris Pkwy), the score was 63.72%.

Below, we invite you to check the detailed review report in the best jewelry stores ranking in Columbus for the fourth place on the list. Detailed report includes analyses related to customer sentiment, trust score, average growth rate, response time to reviews, average review length, or the impact of negative reviews on the overall rating.

Check the detailed report of the fourth place in ranking

5. KAY Jewelers (1500 Polaris Pkwy Suite 2058)

Results from ReviewsAudit:

• ReviewsAudit Score (%): 60.02
• Average Rating: 4.17
• Number of Reviews: 141
• New Reviews in the Last Quarter: 13
• Response Rate to Reviews (%): 12.06
• Percentage of Reviews without Text (%): 38.3

The fifth highest-rated best jewelry store in Columbus, according to customer reviews, is KAY Jewelers (1500 Polaris Pkwy Suite 2058). The average rating from all Google reviews for this jewelry store is 4.17 based on 141 reviews. In the last 3 months, KAY Jewelers (1500 Polaris Pkwy Suite 2058) has received 13 new customer reviews.

Additionally, the jewelry store has responded to 12.06% of all customer reviews, which had a significant impact on the final rating displayed in the jewelry store ranking report.

When it comes to review quality, it can be verified using the percentage of reviews without text (the lower the value, the better). For the fifth place in the ranking, the result was 38.3%.

These are some of the variables that influenced the percentage score in ReviewsAudit. For KAY Jewelers (1500 Polaris Pkwy Suite 2058), the score was 60.02%.

Below, we invite you to check the detailed review report in the best jewelry stores ranking in Columbus for the fifth place on the list. Detailed report includes analyses related to customer sentiment, trust score, average growth rate, response time to reviews, average review length, or the impact of negative reviews on the overall rating.

Check the detailed report of the fifth place in ranking

6. The Smithery (2050 S High St)

Results from ReviewsAudit:

• ReviewsAudit Score (%): 59.39
• Average Rating: 4.83
• Number of Reviews: 36
• New Reviews in the Last Quarter: 8
• Response Rate to Reviews (%): 61.11
• Percentage of Reviews without Text (%): 50.0

The sixth highest-rated best jewelry store in Columbus, according to customer reviews, is The Smithery (2050 S High St). The average rating from all Google reviews for this jewelry store is 4.83 based on 36 reviews. In the last 3 months, The Smithery (2050 S High St) has received 8 new customer reviews.

Additionally, the jewelry store has responded to 61.11% of all customer reviews, which had a significant impact on the final rating displayed in the jewelry store ranking report.

When it comes to review quality, it can be verified using the percentage of reviews without text (the lower the value, the better). For the sixth place in the ranking, the result was 50.0%.

These are some of the variables that influenced the percentage score in ReviewsAudit. For The Smithery (2050 S High St), the score was 59.39%.

Below, we invite you to check the detailed review report in the best jewelry stores ranking in Columbus for the sixth place on the list. Detailed report includes analyses related to customer sentiment, trust score, average growth rate, response time to reviews, average review length, or the impact of negative reviews on the overall rating.

Check the detailed report of the sixth place in ranking

7. Star Jewelers (607 N High St)

Results from ReviewsAudit:

• ReviewsAudit Score (%): 57.23
• Average Rating: 4.82
• Number of Reviews: 22
• New Reviews in the Last Quarter: 1
• Response Rate to Reviews (%): 4.55
• Percentage of Reviews without Text (%): 4.55

The seventh highest-rated best jewelry store in Columbus, according to customer reviews, is Star Jewelers (607 N High St). The average rating from all Google reviews for this jewelry store is 4.82 based on 22 reviews. In the last 3 months, Star Jewelers (607 N High St) has received 1 new customer reviews.

Additionally, the jewelry store has responded to 4.55% of all customer reviews, which had a significant impact on the final rating displayed in the jewelry store ranking report.

When it comes to review quality, it can be verified using the percentage of reviews without text (the lower the value, the better). For the seventh place in the ranking, the result was 4.55%.

These are some of the variables that influenced the percentage score in ReviewsAudit. For Star Jewelers (607 N High St), the score was 57.23%.

Below, we invite you to check the detailed review report in the best jewelry stores ranking in Columbus for the seventh place on the list. Detailed report includes analyses related to customer sentiment, trust score, average growth rate, response time to reviews, average review length, or the impact of negative reviews on the overall rating.

Check the detailed report of the seventh place in ranking

8. Carioti Jewelers (175 Cleveland Ave)

Results from ReviewsAudit:

• ReviewsAudit Score (%): 56.08
• Average Rating: 4.85
• Number of Reviews: 26
• New Reviews in the Last Quarter: 1
• Response Rate to Reviews (%): 15.38
• Percentage of Reviews without Text (%): 26.92

The eighth highest-rated best jewelry store in Columbus, according to customer reviews, is Carioti Jewelers (175 Cleveland Ave). The average rating from all Google reviews for this jewelry store is 4.85 based on 26 reviews. In the last 3 months, Carioti Jewelers (175 Cleveland Ave) has received 1 new customer review.

Additionally, the jewelry store has responded to 15.38% of all customer reviews, which had a significant impact on the final rating displayed in the jewelry store ranking report.

When it comes to review quality, it can be verified using the percentage of reviews without text (the lower the value, the better). For the eighth place in the ranking, the result was 26.92%.

These are some of the variables that influenced the percentage score in ReviewsAudit. For Carioti Jewelers (175 Cleveland Ave), the score was 56.08%.

Below, we invite you to check the detailed review report in the best jewelry stores ranking in Columbus for the eighth place on the list. Detailed report includes analyses related to customer sentiment, trust score, average growth rate, response time to reviews, average review length, or the impact of negative reviews on the overall rating.

Check the detailed report of the eighth place in ranking

9. Diamonds Pearls & Jade (4422 N High St)

Results from ReviewsAudit:

• ReviewsAudit Score (%): 55.37
• Average Rating: 4.65
• Number of Reviews: 23
• New Reviews in the Last Quarter: 2
• Response Rate to Reviews (%): 8.7
• Percentage of Reviews without Text (%): 21.74

The ninth highest-rated best jewelry store in Columbus, according to customer reviews, is Diamonds Pearls & Jade (4422 N High St). The average rating from all Google reviews for this jewelry store is 4.65 based on 23 reviews. In the last 3 months, Diamonds Pearls & Jade (4422 N High St) has received 2 new customer reviews.

Additionally, the jewelry store has responded to 8.7% of all customer reviews, which had a significant impact on the final rating displayed in the jewelry store ranking report.

When it comes to review quality, it can be verified using the percentage of reviews without text (the lower the value, the better). For the ninth place in the ranking, the result was 21.74%.

These are some of the variables that influenced the percentage score in ReviewsAudit. For Diamonds Pearls & Jade (4422 N High St), the score was 55.37%.

Below, we invite you to check the detailed review report in the best jewelry stores ranking in Columbus for the ninth place on the list. Detailed report includes analyses related to customer sentiment, trust score, average growth rate, response time to reviews, average review length, or the impact of negative reviews on the overall rating.

Check the detailed report of the ninth place in ranking

10. Winston Wilson Jewelers (300 S High St)

Results from ReviewsAudit:

• ReviewsAudit Score (%): 54.52
• Average Rating: 4.64
• Number of Reviews: 11
• New Reviews in the Last Quarter: 0
• Response Rate to Reviews (%): 0.0
• Percentage of Reviews without Text (%): 18.18

The tenth highest-rated best jewelry store in Columbus, according to customer reviews, is Winston Wilson Jewelers (300 S High St). The average rating from all Google reviews for this jewelry store is 4.64 based on 11 reviews.

When it comes to review quality, it can be verified using the percentage of reviews without text (the lower the value, the better). For the tenth place in the ranking, the result was 18.18%.

These are some of the variables that influenced the percentage score in ReviewsAudit. For Winston Wilson Jewelers (300 S High St), the score was 54.52%.

Below, we invite you to check the detailed review report in the best jewelry stores ranking in Columbus for the tenth place on the list. Detailed report includes analyses related to customer sentiment, trust score, average growth rate, response time to reviews, average review length, or the impact of negative reviews on the overall rating.

Check the detailed report of the tenth place in ranking